Garage Doors – Roller Door Versus Up and Over Door
If you are thinking of replacing a garage door, then the chances are that you already have an up-and-over door (U and O) and therefore you might want to consider some of the other opening systems that are available. These include the roller, sliding, side hinged and sectional garage doors. If you have a canopy style up and over door, then the retracting version of this door style would see an upgrade “of sorts”.
At the top of the garage door “options” list is the roller garage door. This is generally considered to be the Rolls Royce of household garage doors and there are many good reasons for this, especially when you contrast it with the up and over alternative.
Roller versus up and over
Starting with the operating mechanism, the roller door has a smoother and more effortless motion than the up-and-over. This in turn makes it more durable and gives it a longer life expectancy. It is also difficult to dislodge or damage the roller door’s mechanism which is located above the garage’s opening. The same is not true of the U and O door.
The mechanism of the roller door also makes it ideally suited to motorisation and remote control, something that is not so true of the up and over door, particularly the canopy version. In fact the roller door is probably the best type of door to select if you want an electric operating garage entry system. It is also a door that is stable and secure once in the closed position.
A big advantage that the roller garage door has over the up-and over door is in space utilization. The U and O door requires a free open area, both to the sides of the door opening and in the roof space where the open door is stored. This can limit roof space and it makes it impossible to store taller items to the sides of the walls where the door tilts and lifts.
With the roller style door neither of these issues occur. The door is made from a series of hinged sections that are retracted upwards and then wrap around a cylindrical drum. This means that they take up a minimum of space and do not interfere with the roof space or the areas adjacent to the garage opening.
Another advantage that the roller door has over the U and O is in the ability to open it without it projecting forward beyond the threshold of the garage opening. This means that vehicles (or anything else) can be placed inches from the door when the door is being opened or closed without danger of damage.
A big disadvantage with the up and over garage door is that it has to be either open or closed. Having this kind of door partially open will lead to it either closing or opening on its own and, if in a semi open state, it will project forward. The roller door does not have this problem. It can be left in a partially open state allowing someone to dip under it without it interfering with anything left or stored nearby.
A final advantage of the roller style door is in is in the way that it looks. It has a clean smart appearance when closed or partially open and disappears completely once fully open.
The only downside to the roller garage door is in its cost. The installation is no more complex than any other garage door option, but the door and mechanism do cost more than an U and O or a hinged garage door. But then again you get what you pay for.